Judicial Campaign Message Framework
From Pain to Power | PA Supreme Court
Judicial races run on a different set of rules. A judicial candidate cannot promise how a case will be decided, so "policy" becomes judicial philosophy and record, not legislation. The same four-step path applies, just built for a courtroom, not a statehouse.
WHAT IT DOES Name what happens to real people when courts are unfair, slow, or stacked, without discussing any pending case.
SAY IT LIKE THIS "Right now, a family in this state can wait years for a court date while a corporation's lawyers run out the clock. That is not justice, that is a stall tactic dressed up as a courtroom."
AVOID Do not name a pending case or predict a ruling. Judicial ethics rules forbid it, and it will get the ad pulled.
WHAT IT DOES Paint what it feels like when courts actually work, are fair, and are fast, for everyday people.
SAY IT LIKE THIS "Picture a court where a small business owner and a big corporation walk in and get the exact same shot at a fair hearing, on the same timeline."
AVOID Do not turn this into a policy promise. Vision here is about fairness and access, not outcomes.
WHAT IT DOES Replace "policy" with judicial philosophy: how the candidate reads the law, their record, their temperament, and their independence.
SAY IT LIKE THIS "In twelve years on the bench, this record shows a judge who reads the law as written and rules on the facts, not on who has the bigger law firm."
AVOID Do not campaign on how you would rule on a future issue. Campaign on how you have ruled, and how you think.
WHAT IT DOES Give the concrete civic action: this is a down-ballot race people skip, so the plan has to fight ballot drop-off directly.
SAY IT LIKE THIS "This race is at the bottom of a long ballot, and that is exactly why it gets stolen by low turnout. Here is how you make sure it doesn't: vote the whole ballot, and bring one person with you who usually stops at the top."
AVOID Do not assume name recognition. Judicial races are won or lost on whether people even get to that line on the ballot.
Where To Use This
Use this for candidate bios, retention messaging, endorsement rollouts, and any surrogate remarks. Every message should be checked against the Code of Judicial Conduct before release; when in doubt, keep language in "fairness and access" terms, not case-outcome terms.